Charlton Athletic Online

Charlton Athletic 4 Barnet 1

An excellent performance from Charlton saw them safely through to the Southern section quarter finals of the Johnstone’s Paint Trophy last night. Goals from Izale McLeod, Tamer Tuna, Nicky Bailey, and Scott Wagstaff replied to Barnet’s early opener, and the result could have been even more convincing but for some better finishing.

With competition rules quite strict about who from the first team had to play, Phil Parkinson did well and was able to give a whole group of youngsters a run out in the first team, and also impart some confidence into other squad players. The most important aspect though, was his option to show fans just what Plan B is, should the current league 4-5-1 formation need to be abandoned.

Chris Solly started at right back, with Christian Dailly and Grant Basey in the middle of
defence; Kelly Youga was in his usual left back position. The midfield had Wagstaff on
the right, complimenting Saturday’s midfield triumvirate Matt Spring, Therry Racon and
Bailey. In attack, Deon Burton got his rest, and Tuna and McLeod led the line. With Rob
Elliot in goal, this did seem to me to only start five of the required six players with the most appearances this year, but maybe with Jose Semedo and Lloyd Sam out injured, some leeway is given? The five-man bench consisted of youngsters Jonjo Shelvey, Yado Mambo, Alex Stavrinou, Luke Holden, and goalie Darren Randolph.

Barnet settled better and after plenty of early possession, they took the lead after 12 minutes, when O’Flynn stabbed home after a corner wasn’t cleared. Charlton were struggling to hold the ball for any period at all, and it did take Tuna 20 minutes or so to get into the pace of the game. Once Bailey had set up McLeod for a deflected equalizer three minutes later though, it was pretty much all Charlton.

Wagstaff then set off on a fabulous run, taking the ball past four defenders as he strode through the middle, before stumbling as he got close to firing in a shot. Spring shot over when well set up, and McLeod almost got on a couple of through balls.

Racon then did well and set up space for a shot, though this seemed to be flying well wide when it came to Tuna, and he finished with aplomb, sidefooting past the Barnet ‘keeper (top pic). With a half-time lead, it was Charlton’s game to lose, but they really didn’t seem to be in that mood thankfully.

The atmosphere amongst the 4522 crowd was strange, simply because about 90% of that figure were grouped together in the lower West stand; Barnet did bring a few hundred fans with them, and they sang well all night, and the only other smattering of fans was in the East stand which was opened just before the game started. I was hoping for a new-ish view, but as luck would have it, the tickets bought had me sitting literally within touching distance of my old seat where I sat for 12 years!

Barnet pushed hard in the early parts of the second half, and Elliot made one excellent save to deny Bolasie (who was by far the most dangerous Bees player all night), but with Bailey and Spring controlling midfield, the Addicks were always happy. Stavrinou was a substitute for Racon early in the second half, and soon afterwards Mambo came on for Solly, and his Charlton first team debut, which meant a re-shuffle of the defence, with Basey moving to left back, and Youga over to the right.

With fifteen minute left, Bailey ended the tie as a contest when he rifled in a bullet free kick from 25 yards, the ball thumping into the top corner netting. Just prior to this, the final substitute Shelvey (on for a tiring Tuna) had tried something similar, but his shot had ended up in the empty North stand seats.

The gloss was finally put on the tie by Wagstaff, who finished a very good game for him by scoring a typical breakaway goal. Bailey won the ball in his own half and fed McLeod on the half way line, who turned and had the winger as the only person on the right side of the pitch. The pass was perfect and Wagstaff had time to control and decide what he wanted to do, much as he had when he scored against Walsall a month or so back. This time though, instead of sidefooting into the corner, he blasted the ball high and into the net off the crossbar; even he looked a bit surprised when it bounced down and into the goal. By then, Shelvey had jinked and turned one way, then the other, only to have his shot blocked near the line by a Barnet body.

McLeod then took a knock, or it may have been cramp, and he came off to generous applause, and ten-man Charlton saw out the clock. An excellent all round performance, with good displays from Solly, Mambo, Tuna, Wagstaff, Spring, Youga, Basey, Dailly, McLeod, and man-of-the-match Bailey. The only player not to look comfortable was Alex Stavrinou sadly, who failed to get into the game much, and did seem to be the least welcomed option when team-mates chose who to pass to. He also did not put in many tackles, as the covering midfield player, but did chase well. This may be harsh after such a good all round performance, but he did stand out as the one not getting much positive from it.

Parky’s Plan B, with McLeod and Tuna leading the line, took time to settle, but once Tuna was up to speed, they played well together, and on another day could both have had more goals. McLeod is always going to be selfish when given a shooting opportunity, and that’s OK if he scores, while Tuna does look like he could fill that gap when Shelvey is tired or injured and play just behind the front man (be it Burton or McLeod). Mambo looked solid, provided he had Dailly alongside him, and Solly showed what a competitor he is, and was heavily involved. If Bailey hadn’t had such a good game though, the star for me was Wagstaff, who showed pace, skill, and great crossing and shooting ability; if Lloyd Sam’s groin strain is not better this weekend, Waggy should be an able deputy.

The draw for the area Quarter Final, which could see Charlton drawn against recent opponents Southampton, Hereford, or Norwich, is on Saturday morning.

Labels: Barnet, Charlton

I have never been to a Johnstone's Paint Trophy tie before, so the match versus Barnet on Tuesday night is going to be a first for me. Mind you, Charlton have never had to play in the competition before, so it’s no surprise I’ve never seen one of the games in this trophy competition.

I am proud to say though, that I did attend all of Charlton’s Full Member’s Cup ties in 1986/87, including the two 800+ gates in Croydon, and the Everton away game that went to extra time and penalties. After that came a fraught semi-final which had me on my way out of the ground seconds before the final whistle, only to see a last second equalizer followed by an extra time winner, and then my first visit to Wembley to see our beloved Addicks in action.

When you have seen your team, and in this case Charlton, run out at Wembley, it makes attending all of the early rounds of, let's face it, a Mickey Mouse competition worthwhile, even if we are likely to see some paltry crowds at some of the games we have to play. The crowd at Charlton for this tie is likely to be small, with only the lower West Stand initially being opened, and with a smattering of Barnet supporters stretched out in the Jimmy Seed end behind the goal.

Some fans are of the opinion that it would be good to be out of this competition as quickly as possible, so that the small squad we have can concentrate on getting promotion, our primary aim of course. Others though, think that as the highest placed league club in the southern section of the draw, we should aim to return to Wembley once more, and brush the sides we meet aside. I’m stuck somewhere between the two camps; sure, I’d love a trip to Wembley again, especially new Wembley, but if we get knocked out by Barnet, or in any other forthcoming round, I won’t mind too much as long it has little effect in the league games between now and March.

Whatever point of view Phil Parkinson has, it’s not as if he can just pick a reserve strength team anyway; the competition rules state that – “Each Club shall play its full available strength in all matches. The Board will from time to time issue a policy as to what constitutes ‘full available strength’. Any Club failing to meet this requirement will be required to pay a fine of up to £5,000.” Not being in a position to pay a fine, I guess we have to comply!

The agreed policy it seems is currently that “clubs will be required to include in their starting line-up at least six of the eleven players that have started most often in first team games this season. “ OK, that’s pretty easy to figure out – six of Elliot, Richardson, Youga, Dailly, Llera, Racon, Semedo, Shelvey, Bailey, Burton, and Sam. Picking six from eleven is no easy job, but it gets easier for Parky, because Lloyd Sam is unlikely to be fit after his first half groin injury at Leeds on Saturday, and Jose Semedo is also out of contention with a pelvic strain. So six from nine makes things a little clearer for Parky, and possibly harder for Barnet!

A number of those nine have had injury niggles this season, but have trended to play on through the pain (Richardson, Dailly, Bailey for instance), while others have looked a little tired of late (Shelvey, Burton, Racon for instance). So Parky’s pick will have to be careful, and we do not want to run the risk of further aggravating any loss of first team players before Saturday’s possibly must-win game against Oldham.

Parkinson will therefore have to weigh up each player in turn and see where they can fit in with the need to give some of the bench, and reserves, a run out in a competitive game. Izale McLeod is one who is very likely to start, and with Miguel Llera certain to come back into the side (replacing Sam Sodje who is on international duty) it is a chance for him to regain some confidence. Rob Elliot also seems like a shoe-in to me; it would be an ideal opportunity to give able deputy Darren Randolph a first team match, but the rules requirement looks to preclude this. Kelly Youga seems to enjoy his football, and he hasn’t had either too many games or too many apparent niggles, so I think he will play. I’m sure club captain Nicky Bailey will want to feature against one of his old clubs, and he will probably be given the chance to cement a place back in central midfield once more. That leaves any two from Richardson, Dailly, Burton, Racon and Shelvey. Although they have both looked in need of a break recently, I would play Jonjo in this game, and alongside Bailey in the centre of midfield, giving Therry Racon a rest. This may be just the sort of game where Jonjo can find some space, and put his undoubted talents to the fore, with Bailey playing the holding role alongside him. The other place I would give to Christian Dailly, simply as he needs to work on his partnership with Llera still, and he is also very fit and should be able to cope, even at his age. That would give Fraser Richardson a chance to rest his knee, and Deon Burton a chance for his nose to set better. Most of the players left out will need to be available anyway to make up numbers on the substitutes bench, which I am presuming is still seven players?

This is therefore the team I would like Parky to send out on the first stage of the road to Wembley –

Rob Elliot
Chris Solly
Miguel Llera
Christian Dailly
Kelly Youga
Grant Basey
Nicky Bailey
Jonjo Shelvey
Scott Wagstaff
Izale McLeod
Tamer Tuna

Subs from – Randolph, Richardson, Clark, Jenkinson, Stavrinou, Spring, Racon, Pell, Perkins, Holden, McKenzie, Burton.

Barnet will need to pick six of their team from Ismail Yakubu, Jake Cole, Albert Adomah, Mark Hughes, Paul Furlong, Micah Hyde, Ryan O'Neill, Albert Jarrett, Yannick Bolasie, Kenny Gillet, and John O'Flynn. With a much smaller squad than (even) Charlton, they may play their current starting eleven, or make minimal changes. Hyde (ex-Watford) and Furlong (ex-QPR) are old-hands who should be familiar to most Charlton supporters, while winger Adomah, midfielder Bolasie, plus centre half and captain Yakubu are all skilful youngsters. Barnet have had a decent start to this season, and currently sit fourth in League Two; they beat Millwall 2-0 to reach this stage of the competition, and are the lowest ranked team still in the southern section.

There will also be no extra-time if the game is drawn, with a deadlocked game being decided by a penalty shoot-out at the end of 90 minutes. In previous Full Member’s Cup games I have seen Charlton win a shoot-out at Everton, and lose one at Cambridge United, and it is a few years since we have had a penalty shoot-out at The Valley (was the last the win versus Luton or the defeat to Oxford?).

Hopefully, the referee Mr D Phillips will keep the game open, his cards in his pocket, and there will be no need for 12-yard pot-shots. Pedro45 is predicting a 2-0 victory for the Addicks, which will get the confidence back up and results back on track.

My one-to-watch in this match has to be Izale McLeod, as he is possibly the only player guaranteed to start in my opinion. Izzy has been a regular substitute over the last few games, coming on with 20-odd minutes left to try and make something happen. With a full game ahead of him, let’s hope his pace is too much for Barnet to cope with, and that he has brought his shooting boots with him. We all saw how delighted he was with the goal he scored against Exeter in the last home game, and I hope he can add to his goal record at The Valley. What he will not want to do is take his shirt off and get booked again, as that would leave him just one yellow card shy of a suspension!

Whether you place much importance on this game or not it has to be played and winning breeds confidence. It is a chance for some of the players (McLeod, Tuna, Wagstaff, Basey and Solly) who have been a little shy of first team football to get competitive game time, and push themselves into the picture when the first team are injured, suspended, or not performing as they should. It’s also a chance for some of the established first team to get some confidence back in their ability (Shelvey, and Llera). Let us not dismiss a win as unimportant, but similarly let us not worry about defeat if it should come; whatever happens, we should go home happy - just wrap up warm, it looks like being a wet and cold night!

Come on you Reds!

Labels: Barnet, Charlton, Izale McLeod